A(nother) Short Story about the State of US Healthcare

Who wants a “pre-existing condition” these days?

I thought I’d take a moment to share a few recent thoughts related to the healthcare situation in the United States.

I’m in my late 50s now and have, for the first time, begun spending a lot of time doing close work with my hands. Making jewelry with fine wire and small tools doesn’t put a lot of strain on my hands, but it apparently does work the muscles and joints more than I’m accustomed to.

Arthritis runs in my family. I clearly remember my grandmother on my mother’s side, who lived to be about 90, complaining about it once in a while. She had typical “old lady hands,” that included thick knuckles and crooked joints under wrinkled skin. She’d spent nearly a lifetime doing close work with her hands in a garment factory, starting work when she was as young as 13 and working until many years later when my grandfather had a stroke and she had to stay home to care for him.

I’ve had knee problems on and off throughout my life. They always got worse when I was heavier and disappeared when I lost a lot of weight back in 2012. But before they disappeared — back when I had a lot of disposable income and a decent health care plan — I went to a doctor about it. Arthritis, he said, pointing at the x-rays.

Handxray
X-ray of a hand from Wikipedia. I’ve got my own x-rays around here somewhere.

More recently, a fall off the back of my truck that sprained an ankle apparently fractured some bones in my left wrist, which I’d landed on. While trying to diagnose the occasional swelling and severe pain (caused by “floating bodies,” we later discovered during arthroscopic surgery that removed most of them), the doctor took x-rays. He pointed out the early signs of arthritis in my wrists and hands.

So yeah. I have arthritis.

It’s gotten to the point that it’s starting to bother me enough to seek medical solutions that don’t necessarily include painkillers. (I can take Vitamin I (ibuprofen) without a doctor telling me to, and I’m not interested in anything stronger.) Would exercises help? CBD creams (as everyone keeps telling me)? Heat or ice therapy? Vitamin supplements? I’m not interested in querying Dr. Google because we all know that there’s enough bad advice there to drown out the good advice. I want to visit a doctor, have her take new x-rays, and tell me what I can do to slow the progression of this very common problem.

And here’s the rub.

If I go to an arthritis specialist — provided I can get an appointment with one — I’m making a very public (on my medical records) statement that I have a medical problem bad enough to seek medical help. In other words, I’m admitting I have a condition that, once admitted, becomes a “pre-existing” condition for future health care coverage.

Now, under the Affordable Care Act (ACA, AKA “Obamacare”), as it was passed by the government and enacted into law, pre-existing conditions didn’t matter. But things are different now.

Let me tell you another story about pre-existing conditions prior to the ACA.

Years ago, when I was very heavy, I was having digestive issues that included GERD, heartburn, acid reflux, and vomiting. To this day, I think it was a hiatal hernia but at the time I was unable to find a doctor to offer any advice beyond “take Pepcid AC.” Back in those days, I made the fatal error of mentioning “chest pain” as a symptom. As you might imagine, that triggered a flurry of heart tests, all of which came back negative. I did not have a heart problem, I had a digestive problem. I blogged about this in detail way back in 2010.

This profit-driven nonsense established me in medical records with a “pre-existing heart condition” that didn’t exist. All of the tests came back negative! So when my idiot wasband lost his job (again), made a late COBRA payment, and got our health insurance canceled, the insurance company refused to cover me when they started the insurance back up. I had a “pre-existing heart condition,” they said.

For six of the scariest months of my life, I had no health insurance because a couple of greedy doctors put me through a battery of unnecessary heart tests and an idiot couldn’t manage his money properly. It wasn’t scary because of my health. It was scary because if, during the time I was uninsured, I got some kind of real negative health diagnosis (think cancer) or had an accident at home (think falling down the stairs) that put me into the hospital or long term treatment, I could lose everything I owned. Medical bankruptcy is a real thing here in the United States and I was set up to become a victim.

I got limited insurance coverage back and later got my own damn insurance again so I didn’t have to worry about an idiot screwing things up for me. The ACA really helped things; it was as if those old medical issues simply didn’t exist. And, so far, I haven’t had insurance denied because of these things — although the rate has gone up dramatically since Trump took office. Next year, who knows?

So here I am in 2019. I have arthritis in my hands and want help to prevent it from getting worse quickly. But I’m afraid to make an appointment with a specialist because I’m afraid to get the condition on my medical records. So instead, I’ll keep waiting, letting the condition likely get worse. All because I don’t want to be denied insurance coverage in the future.

Is it right? Does it makes sense? No and no. But there isn’t a damn thing I can do about it other than emigrate to a country with decent health care for all. And believe me, I’ve been thinking about it.

So that’s my situation as I type this.

At least the CBD cream smells nice.


Discover more from An Eclectic Mind

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

12 thoughts on “A(nother) Short Story about the State of US Healthcare

  1. Firstly, sorry you are getting these pains in your hands. I do a fair bit of physical work and ibuprofen usually helps me through the minor aches. Stay clear of the strong stuff unless you really get the screaming habdabs. The drugs that work fast muck up your digestion or can hook you in.
    The US is a leader in so many things but it’s healthcare system is truly gothic. My American uncle Pete was a college principal, had a lovely house on Rhode Island, a yacht and all the trimmings. When the insurance companies dumped him, he had to sell all his assets to pay for care. A cruel end for a couple used to comfort.

    In the UK care is ‘free for all’ but the waits can be so long I have paid cash for minor ops, when needed. Don’t get too romantic about the ‘humane’ European systems.
    Both the ‘pay by tax’ and ‘pay by premium’ systems have grave problems. France, Germany and Holland sort of blend the two methods and those work OK, I hear.

    • Ibuprofen is my go to for pain. But I’m careful not to take it too often because I really think that it will lose its effectiveness if I start relying on it. So far, this problem has been a bit of a nuisance but not so bad that is preventing me from doing the things I want to do. I’m hoping it doesn’t get much worse anytime soon.

  2. Arthritis seems to be in most elderly folks including me in knees, hips, back and now hands which is driving me nuts. My medical providers recommend Tylenol (acetaminophen) over NASID pain relievers because of kidney issues.

    Interested in the CBD cream.

    • Geez! I don’t really consider 57 (almost 58) “elderly.“

      Tylenol has never done anything for me but Ibuprofen is my wonder drug. I try to make sure I take it on a full stomach and don’t take it very often. So far, no problems. I have absolutely no desire to take anything any stronger.

      As for the CBD cream — I’m going to try using it twice a day to see if I notice any difference. The trick is remembering to use it.

  3. Wouldn’t your arthritis info already be in your medical records as a result of the earlier diagnosis? Even though it was several years ago and it wasn’t your primary issue at that appointment as you described it (knee), call me cynical but I’m suspicious enough of our medical (“health care”) system to think it’s in your records, somewhere, and if push came to shove in the future and we no longer have coverage for pre-existing conditions, an insurance company would find the info:(

    • Yes and no. I never really got a diagnosis of arthritis for a problem I went in for. In each case, it was pointed out as an aside. It might be in my records somewhere. I don’t know. But if I go to an arthritis specialist and start getting treatment for arthritis it’ll be recognized as a “problem that requires treatment.”

      And I’m not too naïve to realize that if an insurance company wants to jack up your rates for coverage or deny coverage altogether they can always find something in your records.

  4. The question here Maria is how much pain and loss of motion are you willing to put up with and for how long? A rheumatologist can provide relief from the pain and often retard the progression of the arthritis. However, the longer you wait, the further it progresses and the more difficult it is to manage. So screw worrying about the damn insurance company and take care of yourself…NOW.

  5. Seems to me the real problem started when health insurance cost was forced on employers. When the ACA took away pre-existing conditions, our company insurance would have gone up over 30% in one year except that my company started pushing more of the health care cost onto the employees.

    One of my scripts went from $30 to $300 a month. Except the drug company covers all of my part above $10. How does that make sense?

    People without employers have always had to pay 100% of their premiums. A couple of years ago I decided I was tired of flying to Taiwan every 6 weeks for a 2 week business trip and went part-time thus losing the benefit of having the company pay 80% of my insurance premiums. That was the worst impact of going part-time.

    • As someone who has paid for her own health insurance for most of the past 29 years, I have very little sympathy for employees who have to pay a higher share of health care costs. Frankly, I think that if employees had to pay all of their insurance costs, the system would finally break and be reworked to benefit everyone equally. Right now, there are too many people snug in their employer subsidized healthcare to give a damn about those of us who can’t get it. That’s why you have so many people against the ACA. If they lost their jobs and had to get their own health insurance on their dime, they’d see the world through our eyes, stop fighting change, and work with us to make things better for everyone.

      But this America, where the people are divided in an infinite number of ways. It’s always “us vs. them” and a country can’t be great with that kind of mentality.

What do you think?

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.